Departments



Articles

Less

Letters to the Editor: Mitochondrial Disease Awareness Week
September 24th, 2011

Letters to the Editor: MEDICARE IS THE SOLUTION, NOT THE PROBLEM!
July 30th, 2011

Letters to the Editor: Letter To Editor
July 18th, 2011

Letters to the Editor: Letter: Local Mom & Pop Business Offers Free Marketing Opportunity
June 21st, 2011

Letters to the Editor: Letter: Change is Once Again Happening in Cedar Key
June 14th, 2011

Letters to the Editor: Letter: Oil Spill Claims Litigation Options Still Available
May 23rd, 2011

Letters to the Editor: Letter FROM the Editor
May 18th, 2011

Letters to the Editor: Letter: Time for a New Face
May 18th, 2011

Letters to the Editor: Letter to the Editor: Candidate Responds
May 10th, 2011

Letters to the Editor: Letter: Thank You From Candidate
May 9th, 2011

Letters to the Editor: Letter to the Editor: No Endorsement Given
May 9th, 2011

Letters to the Editor: Letter: Save Gulf Hammock
April 11th, 2011

Letters to the Editor: Letter to the Editor: What More Can We Do to Save Our Libraries?
March 28th, 2011

Letters to the Editor: Letter to the Editor: Fireworks Viewed from Seat #2
March 11th, 2011

Letters to the Editor: Letter: Fishing and Aquaculture Producers Seek Assistance in BP Claims Process
February 6th, 2011

More

Letter to the Editor

Letter to the Editor

As a recent resident of Florida and Cedar Key, I was disheartened to learn of the pollution threatening Cedar Key caused by Buckeye Paper as well as their proposed pipeline 'solution'.. Make no mistake; this WILL adversely affect Cedar Key and its aquaculture industry because of the prevailing Gulf currents.

I came from Michigan where this would never be tolerated today. Back in the 70s when its paper mills ranked with the auto industry and steel mills as major causes of pollution of its air and natural resources, Michigan passed tough Natural Resources legislation, backed by a courageous governor, legislators and Department of Natural Resources director.. This would normally have been considered unthinkable. Nobody ever fought the auto giants and won. Yet they did and once this behavior was firmly entrenched it became the norm.

In the 80s, I was vice president of engineering for a major auto industry supplier,. One of our divisions was a paper mill producing worse stuff than ordinary newsprint.. Yet the effluent leaving the plant had to be potable and the solids were strained out, compressed and used as fuel. When the painting vapors scrubbing system broke down in our body parts stamping division, we had the choice of shutting down Chevrolet – something a parts supplier never did if they wished to remain in business – or pay the $500,000 fine for each day we continued to discharge raw paint solvent fumes into the atmosphere. We had it fixed by the weekend.

The paper mill waste cleaning technology existing today is much more cost effective and efficient than it was in the 80s. In fact, studies have repeatedly shown that the payback of a paper waste treatment plant is excellent. The reason the industry doesn't do it is money. With a waste treatment facility, there are the continuing costs of maintenance and personnel. Dumping waste into a convenient river doesn't cost anything. A pipeline is a one time cost and they can discharge the effluent unabated forever. It is cheaper to buy off a few key politicians and DEP directors by either contributing heavily to their election campaigns, key projects or threatening their jobs. The paper industry is a major industry and its lobby is strong, well-financed and connected, and they are currently fighting, or ignoring, waste treatment legislation in several states. It appears that they have no intention of losing this fight.

Taking Buckeye Paper to court, while it must be done, serves their interests. They can fight this for years and, in the meantime, continue to dump their waste effluent into the Fenholloway River unabated. If they do get the pipeline, so much the better because it improves their processes and they get credit for cleaning up the river.

As Linda Young said in the recent meeting, the answer is people. While politicians will readily take Buckeye's money and their DEP directors will do what is necessary to keep their jobs, they still need people to get elected. All it takes is a governor, a few key legislators and especially a DEP director who have the courage to do the right thing.

Gene Malinowski
Cedar Key

Click for printer friendly version

Email this article to a friend

 

 

© 2013
Cedar Key News

cedarkeynews@gmail.com